In regard to forensic engineering, there is a misconception that engineering documents unrelated to construction are not required to be signed and sealed, but in fact, this is not true for a wide variety of documents, including engineering reports. This article is intended to increase awareness on the vast extent of documents, including engineering reports, that are required to be signed and sealed by engineers.
Florida, Texas, and Arkansas have been used as examples as it concerns the points raised in this article, and cites to their licensure laws have been provided. However, because licensure laws vary from jurisdiction to jurisdiction, practitioners are encouraged to check with each state to ensure full compliance with local rules and statutes.
States such as Arkansas [Article 2.D(1)] and Florida [F.S. 471.005(7)] use the Model Law definition for the Practice of Engineering. This definition basically states that any service or creative work which requires engineering education, training, and experience—such as consultation, investigation, evaluation, planning, and design of engineering works and systems; the inspection of construction for the purpose of determining compliance with drawings and specifications; and such other professional services as may be necessary to the planning, progress, and completion of any engineering service—is the practice of engineering.
However, more and more states have taken Texas’s lead and have begun identifying activities that, in and of themselves, constitute the practice of engineering:
§ 1001.003(c)(1) “The practice of engineering includes consultation, investigation, evaluation, analysis, planning, engineering for program management, providing an expert engineering opinion or testimony, engineering for testing, or evaluating materials for construction or other engineering use”
Therefore, developing and issuing a document or report that contains a professional engineering opinion or engineering directive does, in and of itself, constitute the practice of engineering.
A number of states’ engineering licensure laws identify or define engineering documents as encompassing any instrument of service that expresses a professional engineering opinion or provides an engineering directive.
States such as Texas [§ 1001.401(b)] and Arkansas [Article 12.B.2] identify engineering documents within their rules as being a “plan, specification, plat, or report.” Florida is one of the states that provides a definition of an engineering document:
61G15-30.002(4), F.A.C. “Engineering documents are designs, plans, specifications, drawings, prints, reports, or similar instruments of service in connection with engineering services or creative work that have been prepared and issued by the professional engineer or under his responsible supervision, direction, or control.”
Therefore, if the engineering report contains a professional engineering opinion or engineering directive (both of which fall under “engineering services”), then yes, an engineering report is an engineering document.
Common to all states is the requirement that all final drawings, specifications, plans, reports, or documents prepared or issued by the licensee (engineering documents) related to construction are required to be signed and sealed. Also common to all states such as Florida [F.S. 471.025(1)], Texas [§ 1001.401.(b)], and Arkansas [Article 12.B.2.], is the requirement that all final drawings, specifications, plans, reports, or documents prepared or issued by the licensee and filed for public record or provided to the owner or the owner’s representative be signed and sealed.
To avoid a licensure violation, licensed engineers are best served by simply developing the practice of signing, dating, and sealing any document produced that contains an opinion, directive, or creative work based on or reflecting the practice of engineering. Similarly, any individual not licensed in the state where the project existed should not issue any document that contains an opinion, directive, or creative work based on or reflecting the practice of engineering to avoid the unlicensed practice of engineering.
What separates a reliable fire cause determination from just another speculative opinion? An objective report rooted in scientific facts. In this report, we will examine key considerations that must be top of mind when developing...
Did you know that a residential structure is three times as likely to experience a flood than a fire over the 30-year life of a mortgage? In fact, flooding is the most common type of...
Whether a commercial roof with massive expanses that cover acres of area or a single-family residential structure with two roof slopes, combining expertise with cutting-edge technology better supports the scientific analysis of roofing matters. ...